Does it Matter Which Brand of Motor Oil You Use?

The Internet is abuzz over the latest Blackstone Labs newsletter. OK, “abuzz” may be a stretch. But the newsletter certainly has sent the motor oil geeks among us into a tizzy.


The distinguished oil analysis laboratory sought to answer the age-old question: Does it really matter which brand of motor oil your use?

To find out, the author compared rates of engine wear in four different engines using a variety of leading motor oils on the market. Read the article for yourself to find Blackstone’s answer. If you don’t have the time, I can sum it up with a quote from the second-to-last paragraph: “Whatever differences exist from oil brand to oil brand, we don’t see a lot of difference in terms of wear for most types of engines.”

Blackstone Labs is popular among auto enthusiasts, and it’s easy to see why. We’ve always found their data legitimate and accurate, and we applaud their advocacy of the benefits of oil analysis. Plus, they do a great job of writing their newsletters in an approachable, fun style that appeals to the average gearhead who doesn’t have an engineering degree.

We’d like to build on Blackstone’s interpretation of the data in this edition of its newsletter.

An apple a day

We all know the importance of making apples-to-apples comparisons when analyzing data. Not making proper comparisons can lead to misleading conclusions. Josh might be able to bench press 200 pounds more than Matt, which could lead to the conclusion that Josh takes much better care of himself. Does your conclusion change if you find out that Matt is 90 years old and Josh is 25?

The same principle holds with some of the test results here. In an ideal world, Blackstone would only compare like oil viscosities. For whatever reason, this isn’t the case. In one test of a Subaru 2.5L engine, Shell Rotella T6 5W-40 provided the lowest wear rate (2.03 ppm iron/1,000 miles). But all the other oils tested are 5W-30 viscosities. If you want to dominate a wear test, just use a higher viscosity. Just about any brand of 20W-50 would have likely outperformed the Shell Rotella.

It’s interesting to note that the top-performing 5W-30 in the Subaru test was “AMSOIL 5W-30” (2.09 ppm iron/1,000 miles).

Which brings us to another question. Which specific oils were tested? We formulate several 5W-30 motor oils. Are the oils tested the primary recommendation for that engine?

Blackstone compared rates of iron wear in three other engines, too. Incidentally, the AMSOIL products performed best in two of those three tests.

Now, let’s talk about copper. “AMSOIL 15W-40” (unfortunately, no indication is given to which of our 15W-40 oils was tested) led to the highest ppm of copper in the tested 6.7L Cummins engine (9 ppm). It’s important to note, however, that the AMSOIL product had the highest average mileage on the samples (11,427). Plus, 9 ppm copper is nothing. Polaris Labs, for example, another reputable oil analysis lab, doesn’t flag copper content until it surpasses 89 ppm. Plus, copper in oil isn’t necessarily an indicator of wear. It often originates from oil-cooler tubing.

The money is in the details

In the end, Blackstone’s main point seems to be that minor differences in the rate of iron wear mean very little. Why pay an extra couple bucks a quart for premium oil if it only amounts to a few ppm difference in iron wear rates?

The problem is (and, to its credit, Blackstone alludes to this fact in the article’s conclusion), the rate of iron wear is just a sliver of the overall picture of motor oil performance. We have to consider the oil’s ability to combat performance-robbing deposits due to intense heat; its ability to fight oxidation, which has a direct bearing on service life; its ability to boost fuel economy and so on.

Those factors are becoming more important, too, as engines grow more sophisticated. Today’s hot-running turbocharged, direct-injection engines place greater demands on oil than engines of yesteryear, and looking at only the rate of iron wear doesn’t tell the whole story in terms of performance.

Love…one quart at a time

Not only that, but your buying motivation makes a difference, too.

The people who pay a couple bucks extra per quart are the people who love their vehicles. For them, their car or truck isn’t just an appliance that conveys them to work and back. It’s their identity. It’s part of their personality. They’ve probably given it a pet name normally reserved for a significant other. And they want to protect it – lavish it with the best of the best to ensure it responds with top-notch performance for years.

Those are our people, and AMSOIL is their oil.

Why? Because we pay attention to every last detail, no matter how seemingly trivial. It’s not just wear protection, either. We formulate our synthetic lubricants to combat intense heat, fight deposits and last longer than other oils, delivering more value. That razor-sharp focus has led to what we think stands alone as simply the best motor oil on the market: AMSOIL Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil.

Signature Series…

  • Delivers 75% more engine protection against horsepower loss and wear than required by a leading industry standard*
  • Protects against harmful deposits on turbochargers 4X better than Mobil 1® Extended Performance and 3.6X better than Royal Purple® in industry-standard testing.**

Not only that, but we’re working on a reformulation of our synthetic motor oils, and you’ll see an even better Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil soon. Stay tuned.

For what it’s worth, the AAA agrees that synthetic oil is worth the extra money in a report it recently published.

Here’s what John Nielsen, AAA’s managing director of Automotive Engineering and Repair, said:

Oil protects critical engine components from damage and AAA found that synthetic engine oils performed an average of 47 percent better than conventional oils in a variety of industry-standard tests. With its superior resistance to deterioration, AAA’s findings indicate that synthetic oil is particularly beneficial to newer vehicles with turbo-charged engines and for vehicles that frequently drive in stop-and-go traffic, tow heavy loads or operate in extreme hot or cold conditions.

At the end of the day, it’s a free country – use whatever oil you want. Use five quarts of Filippo Berio extra-virgin olive oil if you want. Just take into account the entire picture of oil performance when you make your choice.

*Based on independent testing of AMSOIL Signature Series 5W-30, in ASTM D7320 as required by API SN specification.
**Based on independent, third-party testing of AMSOIL® Signature Series 5W-30, Mobil1® Extended Performance 5W-30 and Royal Purple® API 5W-30 in the ASTM D6335 bench test required by the API SN Resource Conserving specification.

Amsoil Dealer Note:

Does the brand make a difference? Well it does when people make a statement stereotyping an issue or a problem “due to synthetics” when most of these oils which are in the synthetic category aren’t even synthetic at all. And one company has address those issues but the stereotype remains. Thus the brand does matter.

It’s also a matter of disclosure. What oil company offers data and customer training?? Which companies don’t? Why don’t OEM oil products contain any data or comparisons??

07Mar 2018
Making synthetic oil

Are all Synthetic Oil Groups the Same? Group III vs IV vs V John Baker|Feb 06, 2018 11:27 AM The simple answer No. In fact, there are wide performance differences between base oil categories. Generally speaking, Group IV base oils offer the best performance, Group III second best, and so on in reverse order. But […]

07Mar 2018
Oil Life Monitor

Oil Life Monitors – Everything You Need To Know Josh Kimmes|Jan 22, 2018 3:31 PM For the past couple months, every time I start my truck I hear an annoying “ding” followed by an equaling annoying message saying “Change Engine Oil Soon.” I know what you’re thinking – you’d better change your oil! My oil […]

06Mar 2018
Warranty Secure

Your Polaris, Ski-Doo and Arctic Cat Dealer Can’t Void Your Warranty for Using Aftermarket Parts or Lubricants Andy Arendt|Jan 18, 2018 8:47 AM As in the automotive market, original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) have introduced new snowmobiles, UTVs and other powersports equipment with advanced materials and new technologies. Prices have risen considerably the past 10 years, […]

06Mar 2018
Dobie Gillis Statue thinking w/ Amsoil cap

Your Most Common Motor Oil Questions Answered Ed Newman|Sep 29, 2017 11:14 AM One thing the Internet has done is create a lot more “experts.” In the old days when you had a car maintenance question, you knew whom to ask – ‘ol Mike up the street with grease under his fingernails and a rag […]

06Mar 2018
Sema car on Ford

On the Road to SEMA with Chris Mangum of MAD Industries Ed Newman|Oct 30, 2017 9:40 AM It’s been a lot of fun going to SEMA these past 21 years. SEMA seemed big even back then when the South Hall of the Las Vegas Convention Center didn’t exist yet. Today it’s massive and still bursting […]

06Mar 2018
clean your battery terminals with AMSOIL MP

How to Clean and Prevent Battery Terminal Corrosion John Baker|Mar 27, 2017 10:46 AM We’ve all been there before. You turn the key on your car and…nothing. Not even the tell-tale clicking sound of the starter solenoid. Your first reaction is to pound the steering wheel and curse the darkness. But it should probably be […]